a) Delay of the production
Neill Blomkamp's sequel would follow Ridley's Prometheus sequel Alien: Paradise Lost. By November 2015, Blomkamp was in talks to write an adaption of the unpublished scifi novel "The Gone World", and then by July of 2016, that was the film he would be directing next and Sigourney was off to join Cameron's Avatar sequels. Had they not been forced to delay for Ridley's Prometheus sequel that would also become an Alien movie, they would surely have made it by the middle of 2016.
b) The path forks
And it would be more associated with Ripley than Ridley's movie, it was a completely different angle in terms of the Alien saga, as more of a sequel, and Ridley's Alien movie was coming in from the back end. It didn't matter that it Blomkamp's Alien movie would veer off from the path in terms of where Alien 3 and Alien Resurrection went, it was accepted that the path forked after Aliens, following the idea that each director wanted to create a whole new set of circumstances.
c) Sigourneys views on the script
Sigourney thought that while the story went off in its own direction, it was written in a way that satisfied, in Sigourney's opinions, the primal needs of the aliens, whatever that meant, but it would also give Ripley an ending. It was also a tribute to the great work that the other directors had done. Did she wish to include Fincher and Jeunet amongst those other directors?
d) Ridley's viewa
With Neill Blomkamp and Sigourney Weaver wanted to do this Alien V, or was it called Alien Awakening? Ridley said "Fine", and he was going to be producer, if he could have, he would have, except that he didn't understand why they should have two Alien films out at the same time, Ridley's own Alien films were about asking questions and Blomkamp's didn't, so he thought it was like shooting ones big toe off and this didn't make sense. Around this time Rudkey asked Neill not to make his Alien sequel until Ridley had made his Prometheus sequel that would be released first. Although Sigourney Weaver was quite sure that they had a great script, curiously all Ridley could acknowledge was that the project was based on a ten page pitch and the script he saw wasn't actually evolving.
Fox didn't appear to be interested in the concept, and it appeared as if Ridley decided to keep out of it, because as far as he was concerned, he re-ignited this franchise to bring it off the ground again because it was lying there dormant on the shelf, and he had enough on his plate with preparing the Alien Covenant movie. Blomkamp appeared to take note of Ridley unwillingness to push, he didn't wish to put the blame on him and let the matter rest. Somewhere in February 2019, it seemed as if Cameron almost suggested that he talking to Blomkamp about his film project but nothing more was said
Or it was a case of both projects
were moving forward at Fox simultaneously and one of them was picked.
Fox just clearly doesn’t want it his Alien V. So by then he didn't haven’t had anything to do with it
He felt bad for Sigourney because she was very into what he had brought forwards as an idea and he felt for the audiences who loved Aliens who wanted a continuation on that vision as he thought that there was an opportunity to do one more film with Sigourney that might have satiated what people were looking for and he thought that he was looking for.
He thought that it was strange how the project came to an end. However having worked on this film project for two years and have it pulled out from under his feet meant that he didn't really want to know Ridley Scott, and so clarification about the situation was never givenIf he was asked to come back and do the film, he was not sure that he would do the project, and then it would be a question of getting him interested enough into wanting to do it again.
- So what does this mean for Neill Blomkamp’s sequel? There had been speculation that Alien: Paradise Lost might mean that it wouldn’t get made, but Sir Ridley has scotched those rumours. “I’m producing it,” he reiterated. “The design is for it to go out next, after this. This will go out first. It’s more associated with Ripley, it’s a completely different angle, it’s more of a sequel. I’m coming in from the back end.” (25th September 2015 http://www.empireonline.com/news/story.asp?NID=45507)
- Иeill Blomkamp
@NeillBlomkamp alien is kinda holding/ pending prometheus 2. So I shall be working on other things... as much as I love the xeno- and Lt ripley (Twitter
- Posted November 11 2015 — 11:42 AM ESTNeill Blomkamp is in talks to write the script for and direct Fox’s movie adaptation of The Gone World, a forthcoming sci-fi novel from Thomas Sweterlitsch, EW has confirmed. (http://www.ew.com/article/2015/11/11/neill-blomkamp-talks-write-direct-gone-world)
- Sigourney Weaver: Well, we have a great script. Fox asked us to delay so Ridley Scott could shoot his [second] Prometheus movie. That was too bad because we would have already done it by now. (http://www.ew.com/article/2016/07/13/sigourney-weaver-aliens-sequel-neill-blomkamp)
- Scott’s film is shooting now and comes out in August 2017, but that doesn’t mean Blomkamp’s Aliens follow-up will start right away. “Now that we’re waiting for that, I have a couple of Avatars to do and Neill has The Gone World,” Weaver says. “So we’ll have to see what happens when we get back, when those projects are over.”(http://www.ew.com/article/2016/07/13/sigourney-weaver-aliens-sequel-neill-blomkamp)
- Either way, she sounds determined to revisit Ellen Ripley. “It’s a great story and it’s satisfying to me to give this woman an ending,” Weaver says, which makes it sound like this would be her final go-round as the character. That means resolution — not that Ripley will necessarily die. (Note that she’s died before, and that obviously didn’t end anything.) (http://www.ew.com/article/2016/07/13/sigourney-weaver-aliens-sequel-neill-blomkamp)
- Weaver also suggested Blomkamp’s Aliens sequel will delve into the motivation of the aliens themselves, exploring what it is their race has been seeking. “The script itself has so much in it that’s so original, but also really satisfies the, I would say, the primal needs of the aliens,” Weaver says. “It’s a tribute to all of the great work that the other directors have done, in a way, but goes in a completely new direction. I hope we’ll do it.”(http://www.ew.com/article/2016/07/13/sigourney-weaver-aliens-sequel-neill-blomkamp)
- After teaming up on 2014’s Chappie, Weaver also seems eager to join forces again with Blomkamp. “We’ve just finished something else together that I can’t talk about, but you know, I hope so,” she says. “But you never know in this crazy business. In any case, [the Aliens sequel] there and waiting for us. He and I both have these other commitments that are finally upon us, and so we’ve got to switch gears and concentrate on that. But it will be worth the wait when we finally get to it.”(http://www.ew.com/article/2016/07/13/sigourney-weaver-aliens-sequel-neill-blomkamp)
- There’s no doubt whatsoever — if the movie happens, it will redirect
the story from the third and forth installments, David Fincher’s Alien3 1992) and Jean-Pierre Jeunet’s Alien: Resurrection (1997).
“It’s just as if, you know, the path forks and one direction goes off
to three and four and another direction goes off to Neill’s movie,”
Weaver says. “It’s just more, I would say, following Jim Cameron’s story
about these characters, rather than just ending up in this sort of
monastery in space, which was [Alien3 screenwriter] Vincent
Ward’s idea and Fox elected to go in that direction. I think Fincher was
fine with that. Each director kind of wanted to create a whole new set
of circumstances. In this case, it picks up, it follows directly the
circumstances of Jim Cameron’s Aliens.”(http://www.ew.com/article/2016/07/13/sigourney-weaver-aliens-sequel-neill-blomkamp)
- For those looking forward to seeing that story realized in a few years, Weaver has encouraging words.
“I hope it won’t be a few. I hope it’ll be a couple. But we’ll see. Yeah.” (http://www.ew.com/article/2016/07/13/sigourney-weaver-aliens-sequel-neill-blomkamp)
- Ridley Scott: They wanted to do Alien, er, Awakening - Neill Blomkamp. I said fine. I was going to be the producer. If I could have, I would have. Except I do question - why have both [Blomkamp's Alien and Scott's Alien] out there? It seems like shooting your big toe off - it doesn't make sense.(http://uk.ign.com/articles/2017/05/09/alien-covenant-sequel-will-begin-shooting-within-14-months-says-ridley-scott)
- Ridley Scott: But they didn't go forward with it, Fox, so I just kind of kept out of it. I mean, I'd literally ignited this thing to bring it off the ground again, because it was lying there dormant on a shelf. I had this thing to bring it back up - but here we are. (http://uk.ign.com/articles/2017/05/09/alien-covenant-sequel-will-begin-shooting-within-14-months-says-ridley-scott)
- Ridley Scott: It's good when it's good. If the sequel's good, then it's worthwhile. (http://uk.ign.com/articles/2017/05/09/alien-covenant-sequel-will-begin-shooting-within-14-months-says-ridley-scott)
- Allocine: What do you think of the project that Neill Blomkamp started for Alien number 5 with the return of Sigourney Weaver, Weaver in it?
Ridley Scott: Well, there was never a script, it was an idea which was evolved on I think a ten page pitch, and I was meant to be part of the producer on that and it didn't evolve. Fox just deiced that they didn't want to do it, so that was it, so I just, I was already onto, I think I had done Prometheus and I was already planning Covenant so, don't know
Allocine: That's never going to happen
Ridley Scott: I don't think so, no (Transcription from video of interview at http://www.allocine.fr/ 27 april, 2017)
Signourney did an appearance last month at tech giant VMware (thanks Cindy and Chris!), and when asked about the state of the project, she said:
Well, I *think* it is. Ridley asked Neill NOT to make our Alien til after Prometheus 2. He (Ridley) wanted his movie to shoot and be released first. But it’s an AMAZING script, and Neill and I are REALLY excited about doing it. We’re doing other things until we can get going on that. I’d be really surprised if we DIDN’T do it, because it’s such a great script, and we love working together. So, it’s just going to take a little bit longer to get out to you, but it’ll be worth the wait.
Needless to say, the audience reacted strongly to this, and here’s hoping. Ellen Ripley has yet to let us down.
- When asked if the project could come back to life in the future, Blomkamp confirmed with ComicBook.com, "No, would be my guess. I would say nothing will come out. But, who knows? At this present moment, I would say it's just dead." (https://comicbook.com/horror/news/alien-5-neill-blomkamp-reaction-future-franchise-disney-update/)
- IGN interviewer "After After, when Tim takes care of that, can you give Neill Blomkamp a call about Aliens just to please me"
Jim Cameron “I’m working on that. yah".
( IGN interview "James cameron: what would Sarah Connor think of Alita? 7th Feb 2019)
- Blomkamp: What are other sci-fi favourites of yours?
Rogan: That's why I was really excited when I heard that you were at least potentially at one point in time thinking about doing an Alien
Blomkamp:Yuh, it would have been cool
Rogan: What happened?
Blomkamp:It's just, you know, it's just studio politics and the um, I do think that they way that Chappie was received probably played a role in me not working on Alien, uh, but uh, you know, it's it's Ridley's world that he created and it's like it should be his to do with what he wants with so it's all good
Rogan: Yuh, I get that but still it would have been fun
Blomkamp:Yuh, yuh, it would have been fun for me as well , I mean, the the thing that I would have enjoyed about it was sigourney weaver was really down for what I'd written and she'd, that. the main thing to me was, even though I like Alien 3, and I love Fincher as a director, I just wanted a version of , of the continuation of what happened after Aliens and for Newt to be alive and for, you know, for Ripley to continue that story erm and it was so based on that idea
Rogan: Is the kid who played Newt old, how old is she now
Blomkamp:Um, I, I mean in my story she would be, she was in her kind of mid twenties, um in real,... Alien, Aliens just turned 35 so she must be like you know, forty four, something like that
Rogan: Isn't that wild?
Blomkamp:Yuh (The Joe Rogan Experience #169, August 2021, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y8zuLUNyVK4)
- What’s the status with the Alien film you’ve long been attached to make?
I don’t know, to be honest. I’m not sure that I would do that project. My assumption is that it’s completely dead.
It was a case of both projects were moving forward at Fox simultaneously, and one of them was picked. Sigourney was unbelievably supportive and amazing. I have nothing but the best things to say about Sigourney. I’m such a fan of hers on every level. She was always into the project, but Fox just clearly doesn’t want it. I haven’t had anything to do with that for years.
Every year there seems to be new concept art leaked that gets a huge reaction from Alien fans wanting to know if it will ever happen. But, it’s easy to forget you might no longer be in the same mind space...
I wonder if it’s possible to do an entire loop, where your’e really into it up until the point it gets shut down, then you lose interest and years go by and you loop all the way back around to being really into it again. Maybe that’s hypothetically possible.
Maybe Alien 5 will be the last film you ever do.
- Neill Blomkamp has provided an update on the status of Alien 5, which he has long been attached to direct.
Blomkamp’s film, which would have been a sequel to James Cameron’s 1988 sequel Aliens, was put on “temporary hold” at the request of Alien director Ridley Scott.
In 2017, Ellen Ripley star Sigourney Weaver, said: “Ridley asked Neill not to make our Alien ‘til after Prometheus 2; he wanted his movie to shoot and be released first.”
Now, in an interview with The Independent, Blomkamp has revealed the film is officially not happening.
“My assumption is that it’s completely dead,” the District 9 director said.
Reflecting on the situation, Blomkamp continued: “It was a case of both projects were moving forward at Fox simultaneously and one of them was picked. Fox just clearly doesn’t want it. I haven’t had anything to do with that for years.”
He had nothing but nice words to say about Weaver.
“Sigourney was unbelievably supportive and amazing,” he said. “I have nothing bu the best things to say about Sigourney. I’m such a fan of hers on every level. She was always into the project.”
- One person who he suggests Chappie wasn’t
for was Ridley Scott, the gatekeeper of the Alien franchise, who
earlier that year had expressed interest in Blomkamp’s concept for a
sequel. In February, it was announced.
In March, Chappie was released. In October, it was cancelled. “It’s
possible that Ridley watched Chappie and he was like, this guy can’t do
Alien so let’s just go ahead and move on,” he says with a smile.
Blomkamp’s film would have carried on from James Cameron’s Aliens, bringing back Sigourney Weaver, who also starred in Chappie. The collapse was hard on him. “I also felt bad for Sigourney because she was really into what I had brought forward,” he says. “I felt like [for] audiences who loved Aliens, there was an opportunity to do one more film with Sigourney in a way that may have satiated what people were looking for and what I think I was looking for.” He adds: “What doesn’t make sense is that I feel like it’s what the audience wanted so it’s strange because Fox would never really turn down money.”
I ask if he spoke to Scott after, if any more specific clarification was given. “Not after, no no no, there’s no coming back from that,” he says. “I’m not gonna work on a film for two years and have the rug pulled out from underneath me and then go hang out and have beers. It’s exactly why I don’t want to do IP based on other people’s stuff ever again.” (He also denied a report that emerged earlier this year that his Alien film was back on track: “I’m sure they will make many films with that piece of IP, it just doesn’t include me.”)
His comment about intellectual property seems extreme, especially given his dalliances with other franchises but when I ask if he’s serious, he relents a tad. “It’s not that black and white,” he says. “If there’s something amazing and the set-up is right, I wouldn’t say no but generally speaking after Halo and after Alien, it would be unwise to do that.” (https://www.theguardian.com/film/2021/aug/21/neill-blomkamp-interview-demonic-chappie-alien)